So that's where the death happened. The way they were laying didn't seem natural. I wasn't sure if they were killed here or else where. They were just too close together to be normal.
But if it was the dining hall, there will be proof of death there, depending on the blood. Most likely is poison of some far, but it's rare a cause of death if confirmed only by what's happened to their face.
I will now make my counter for your theory.
[Holds up a finger.] First, I'll address your feelings. You are a watcher. These people doubt whether or not you existence, so your relationship is only one sided. Further more, Krauss, Shannon, and Gohda are the only three on this island regularly. We know that it's likely you hate Rosa for her treatment of Maria, so perhaps if she got a special death, your theory would hold water. The thing is, she was with the majority. Rudolf and Kyrie were just visitors. Maybe you'd hate them, but you wouldn't hate them especially.
The three who are always on the island and Rosa, if it was these four who had their faces bashed in, it could be believed that you hold a particular hate for them, but the fact you hit the other two who are usually just visitors with the worst, it seems odd.
Gohda is a cook, a servant. If it were him and Shannon spared, since they wouldn't show greed and such like the family members, it might work. Shannon, you could excuse. She seems just a nice servant, at least.
But Krauss is the one who stands out. If destroying half his face was to make it a point that he was being punished, then why didn't you do that with Rosa, to make it a point that just leaving Maria like that is unforgivable as well? No, the reason Krauss was spared was because the person hated him less than the others. Especially when you have a reason to hate him especially. He believed in your gold, but denied it to others. He'd openly deny your existence while thinking otherwise. It'd be insulting if I was in your place.
[Holds up a second finger.] The second point. You left the faces untouched so all the bodies could be identified? That's doubtful. The question is again why only those two? To destroy only two, that's more likely to make people think the four you can't tell are trying to pull a trick when, as Kyrie says, you turn the chessboard around. If you wanted to seal your proof, you'd have left half of the face for everyone, not just those two.
He talks a lot.
But if it was the dining hall, there will be proof of death there, depending on the blood. Most likely is poison of some far, but it's rare a cause of death if confirmed only by what's happened to their face.
I will now make my counter for your theory.
[Holds up a finger.] First, I'll address your feelings. You are a watcher. These people doubt whether or not you existence, so your relationship is only one sided. Further more, Krauss, Shannon, and Gohda are the only three on this island regularly. We know that it's likely you hate Rosa for her treatment of Maria, so perhaps if she got a special death, your theory would hold water. The thing is, she was with the majority. Rudolf and Kyrie were just visitors. Maybe you'd hate them, but you wouldn't hate them especially.
The three who are always on the island and Rosa, if it was these four who had their faces bashed in, it could be believed that you hold a particular hate for them, but the fact you hit the other two who are usually just visitors with the worst, it seems odd.
Gohda is a cook, a servant. If it were him and Shannon spared, since they wouldn't show greed and such like the family members, it might work. Shannon, you could excuse. She seems just a nice servant, at least.
But Krauss is the one who stands out. If destroying half his face was to make it a point that he was being punished, then why didn't you do that with Rosa, to make it a point that just leaving Maria like that is unforgivable as well? No, the reason Krauss was spared was because the person hated him less than the others. Especially when you have a reason to hate him especially. He believed in your gold, but denied it to others. He'd openly deny your existence while thinking otherwise. It'd be insulting if I was in your place.
[Holds up a second finger.] The second point. You left the faces untouched so all the bodies could be identified? That's doubtful. The question is again why only those two? To destroy only two, that's more likely to make people think the four you can't tell are trying to pull a trick when, as Kyrie says, you turn the chessboard around. If you wanted to seal your proof, you'd have left half of the face for everyone, not just those two.